Amended Bitter Orange - Ephedra in Disguise? So Why Do People Still Take It ?

If you read my last article about bitter orange, it was pretty clear how I felt about the herb. I'd read the available research concerning bitter orange, and while there was some evidence supporting bitter orange, the overall picture did not look good.

So that's the picture I painted, however, there were some facts that I was unaware of at the time, which I felt you might be interested in if you're researching bitter orange.

In order to lay these out, I want to answer four questions:

1. What Is Bitter Orange Really ?

2. So does Bitter Orange act similarly to ephedrine ?

3. What about the reports of adverse ill effects of bitter orange ?

4. Is bitter orange safe to use and does it work ?

It's a bit long, but what the heck !

What Is Bitter Orange Really ?:

The Bitter Orange extract found in popular fat burners, is made from the unripe fruit of the citrus aurantium tree. The fruit is picked when they are a dark green in color, halved, dried and then milled into a powder. This makes the herb Zhi Shi1. Bitter orange is the western name for Zhi Shi.

The bitter orange herb contains five alkaloids (see alkaloid definition5), the most dominant of which is Synephrine (the compound I referred to in my last article), structurally similar to ephedrine. However, while they are similar, they're not the same.

Both synephrine and ephedrine stimulate the sympathetic nervous system and at a cellular level, affect alpha cell receptors, and to a lesser extent, beta cell receptors6. Ephedrine will affect beta(1), beta(2) and beta(3) cell receptors, however, of the beta-cell receptors, synephrine appears to only affect beta(3) cells, those believed to be responsible for thermogenesis or fat burning affects7. Beta(1) and beta(2) receptors are believed to be responsible for cardiac and pulmonary functions.

So does Bitter Orange act similarly to ephedrine ?

Does it ? While previously, I've presented a very black and white view of whether it acts similarly to ephedrine, I am now not so sure.

There is some confusion as to how synephrine affects heart rates and blood pressure. Intravenously injected synephrine will cause increased heart rates and blood pressure, however, orally taken synephrine does not, and synephrine contained in most herbal weight loss supplements are taken orally.

Generally speaking because synephrine stimulates beta(3) cells but not beta(2) and beta(1) cells, it can provide the thermogenic effects without the undesirable cardiac side effects that ephedrine did.

What about the reports of adverse ill effects of bitter orange ?

The American Herbal Products Association has found that there were errors in the reported adverse event reports attributed to the use of bitter orange in September 20043. The association found that numbers reported in the media were in fact duplicates for adverse event reports for ephedrine, and when all was said and done, there was really only one report of an adverse reaction attributed to a bitter orange supplement, where no other ingredient was included in the supplement. In this particular case, it involved a 74 year old woman had been taking prescription medication and two other herbal preparations simultaneously. This one case occurred more than five years ago3.

What about the 55 year old woman reported by Nykamp DL, Fackih MN, Compton AL (2004), who experienced chest pain after consuming a supplement containing bitter orange. Researchers in this case study had commented "Based on the Naranjo probability scale, C. aurantium is possibly associated with this cardiovascular event"4, however, as bitter orange was not the only ingredient in the supplement, it cannot be known whether in this case, that bitter orange was the herb responsible.

Is bitter orange safe to use and does it work ?

Now there are many others, who felt as I did, that bitter orange is another Ephedra waiting to happen, and will have the same consequences. However, when bitter orange is taken in isolation, it does not have adverse side effects.

In fact, when it is combined with other selected herbs, it may have benefits for health and weight loss. Research performed with 20 individuals over six weeks found no adverse reactions occurred when citrus aurantium was combined with caffeine and St. Johns Wort2. They also found that the individuals who were given the supplement (group A) lost an average of 2.9% body fat. "In terms of actual fat loss, group A lost a significant amount (3.1 kg), whereas the control group demonstrated a tendency toward fat loss." So, this study has demonstrated that there are weight loss benefits involved here, but also the control group who received nothing exhibited a tendency towards fat loss, suggesting that if the study had been extended beyond 6 weeks, the control group would have lost body fat as well.

Conclusions:

2004 was not a great year for bitter orange in the media. It has successfully battled reports of adverse events alleged to be a result of consuming bitter orange. These numbers proved to be incorrect.

While synephrine the main alkaloid of bitter orange, is chemically similar to ephedrine, it is not the same as ephedrine and differs in the way it reacts pharmacologically within the human body.

Although at first look at the research, bitter orange presented with dangers that I wanted to warn against, a more in-depth look has revealed that bitter orange by itself is not dangerous. The citrus aurantium extract standardized for synephrine (3-6%) is accepted as safe7.

But hang on, before you click off this page, to go and find a fat burner with citrus aurantium in it, I do also want to say, that they can't be used as an alternative to good food and exercise.

Herbal supplements such as those containing bitter orange can be helpful but only when used within a weight loss strategy of balanced eating and exercise, and while they may benefit some, it may not benefit others and only your doctor will be able to make that decision for you6. The results may be slower, but a balanced diet and exercise are the keys to permanent and healthy weight loss. So while bitter orange may be helpful, you can obtain the same results without it. What-ever stage you are at with your health and fitness, diet and exercise are the two most important aspects.

If you do decide you'd like to try a supplement containing bitter orange, please consult your doctor before purchasing a bitter orange product.

Essentially if you consult your doctor about bitter orange, as we say in Australia - you can't go wrong, mate. Your doctor will be able to refer you to your nearest dietician and will recommend the best weight loss strategy for your situation.

References:

1. Jones, D., "Bitter Orange or Citrus Aurantium: same difference ?"

2. Colker et. al., (1999) Effects of Citrus Aurantium extract, caffeine, and St. John's Work on body fat loss, lipid levels, and mood states in overweight healthy adults. Curr. Ther. Res. 60, 145 ? 153.

3. American Herbal Products (2004) "FDA Spins Numbers on Bitter Orange AERs" Press Release

4. Nykamp DL, Fackih MN, Compton AL. Possible association of acute lateral-wall myocardial infarction and bitter orange supplement. Ann Pharmacother. 2004 May;38(5):812-6. Epub 2004 Mar 16.

5. Definition of Alkaloids - any of hundreds of compounds found in plants with a nitrogen atom connected to two carbon atoms, and often formed in a ring structure. Many commonly known chemicals and drugs are alkaloids, including nicotine, cocaine, quinine, morphine, and ephedrine.

6. Dharmananda, S., SYNEPHRINE:Is Chih-shih (Zhishi) Toxic? Institute for Traditional Medicine, Portland, Oregon. See the schematic diagram for synephrine at the bottom of the page.

7. Supplement Watch on Synephrine

Other Sites of Interest:

Supplement Watch Newsletter

About The Author

Copyright 2004 Jenny Mathers All Rights Reserved.

Research resource for fat burning foods and supplements. Fat burning food research information allowing you to take the guess work out of fat burning.

In The News:


Study: Easy does it on Vitamin D supplements for obese teens
Lompoc Record
"After three months of having vitamin D boosted into the normal range with supplements, these teenagers showed no changes in body weight, body mass index, waistline, blood pressure or blood flow," Kumar said. "We're not saying the links between vitamin ...


Latinos Health

Omega 3 supplements not beneficial for cognitive decline: study
Latinos Health
"Contrary to popular belief, we didn't see any benefit of omega-3 supplements for stopping cognitive decline," said lead author Dr. Emily Chew, deputy director of the Division of Epidemiology and Clinical Applications, as reported by the New York Times.
Well | Supplements Don't Fight Cognitive Decline, NIH Study SaysNew York Times (blog)
The Study Says Omega-3 Supplements Ineffective In Preventing NeurodegenerationPioneer News
Omega 3 supplements not effective on older persons with AMDThe Hoops News
KRWG News22 -NYC Today
all 89 news articles »

Male eating disorder? New report on workout supplements
Military Times
Theodore recently co-wrote a paper with psychologist Richard Achiro to study whether the use of dietary supplements such as protein powders, creatine and other performance- and muscle-enhancing boosters contribute to unhealthy eating habits — and ...


The Inquisitr

FDA Powdered Caffeine Warning About Supplements After Deaths: How Much Coffee ...
The Inquisitr
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) wants consumers to beware of pure powdered caffeine. Usually sold in supplements, caffeine powder overdoses have killed two people. As a result, five distributors have received the FDA's letters about their ...
Pure Powdered Caffeine a Serious Health Risk: FDAWebMD
FDA warns powdered caffeine distributors about safety concernsUPI.com
What Happens to Your Body After Taking Pure Powdered CaffeineYahoo Health
eMaxHealth -The Consumerist
all 262 news articles »

Medical Xpress

Supplements, exercise could improve muscle mass and strength for older adults
Medical Xpress
Rick Sharp, a professor of kinesiology, is testing the effectiveness of a combination of supplements and resistance training in older adults with low vitamin D levels. The trial is designed to build on previous studies, which show that the supplement ...

and more »

The Hill (blog)

FDA cracks down on dietary supplements
The Hill (blog)
In April this year, the FDA expanded its policy of restricting the sale of adulterated dietary supplements containing untested additives. Many of the substances targeted are dangerous and worthy of restriction. The synthetic additive DMAA is one such ...


Duluth News Tribune

Multivitamins and supplements: To take or not to take?
Duluth News Tribune
For some people, however, taking certain supplements may be the best way to get nutrients they may be lacking through diet. So, Harguth cautions, it's important to understand the exact impact supplements will have on your body before getting out your ...
Lowdown on taking vitamins, supplementsWatertownDailyTimes.com

all 2 news articles »

Newsweek

Omega 3 is still good for the brain. But 'fish oil supplements just don't cut it.'
Washington Post
Consumers may want to rethink popping fish oil pills if they're hoping those supplements full of omega-3 fatty acids will keep their brains healthy. A new study--one of the largest and longest in duration of its kind--finds that taking omega-3 ...
Omega-3 Supplements Are a Waste of MoneyNewsweek
Study questions benefits of fish oil supplementsFox News
NIH study shows no benefit of omega-3 or other nutritional supplements for ...National Institutes of Health (press release)
Chicago Tribune -TIME -UPI.com
all 161 news articles »

Quad City Times

Environmental Nutrition: Take supplements safely
Quad City Times
More than half of Americans use dietary supplements, including multivitamins and botanical supplements, in tablet, capsule, liquid and powder form, says the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. While dietary supplements -- products intended to ...


Care2.com

Antioxidant Supplements: Good News and Bad
Care2.com
They concluded that the idea that antioxidant supplements can prevent chronic diseases has not been proved or even consistently supported by intervention trials. They suggest further evidence is needed and until that time to increase consumption of ...

Google News

Ganoderma Lucidum - The Wonder Herb

One of the most apparent influences modern times has brought... Read More

Creatine: More than a Sports Nutrition Supplement

Although creatine offers an array of benefits, most people think... Read More

Vitamin A and C: How They Affect The Skin

Benefits of using Vitamin A products:Retinol is pure and active... Read More

Taurox SB: A Balanced Immune System Leads to Increased Energy

Taurox is an excellent way to find true and healthy... Read More

Ganoderma Herbal Supplements ? Natures Gift to Humanity

Use of herbs and herbal therapies has been an integral... Read More

Balancing Your Hormones Naturally -- What To Do First

One of the questions that I frequently get asked is... Read More

What Is The Best Muscle Building Supplement Available Today?

What's the best muscle building supplement available today? You might... Read More

Dietary Supplement Vitamin

Dietary Supplement Vitamin - why is it important?Dietary supplement vitamin... Read More

Getting In-Zinc

As with most nutrients and minerals, zinc is often ignored... Read More

Herbal Supplement

Herbal Supplement ? what is it?So what is an herbal... Read More

PhytoNutrients

We have all heard that it is important to eat... Read More

The Benefits of Whey Protein Drinks

Whey proteins drinks, especially shakes, are available in a variety... Read More

Some Vitamin Supplements to Enhance Your Ironman Training Diet

There are a host of choices for supplementing your Ironman... Read More

How to Know if You Need Vitamin Supplements

Taking vitamin and mineral supplements is perhaps one of the... Read More

Vitamin E - The Wonder Vitamin

Vitamin E is a family of eight related molecules known... Read More

Take Back Your Life 2

In part one of this series, titled "Take Back Your... Read More

GlutImmune: Powder for Immunity and Digestion

GlutImmune? is a very convenient high absorption source of glutamine.... Read More

Healthy Eating isnt Enough, You Need Supplements, Real Health Part 3

The next step on your road to real health is... Read More

Side Effects of Hyaluronic Acid Products

Currently, there are no known side effects for most hyaluronic... Read More

Side Effects of Fish Oil

Fish oil is oil derived from the tissues of fatty... Read More

Improve Your Mental Cognitive Abilities

The Connection Between Brain Inflammation, Alzheimer's and Parkinson's DiseaseThe evidence... Read More

Zma Fuel

Zma is a unique combination of vitamins and minerals that... Read More

When Your Body Lacks Vitamins

The body needs a minimum amount of vitamins and minerals... Read More

Folate (Folic Acid) - A Health Supplement

You probably know that ladies who are planning on having... Read More

Bodybuilding Supplements May Not Be Necessary

To supplement or not to supplement ? that is the... Read More